UK marketplace profit comparison

Etsy vs eBay Fees Calculator

Compare the same UK order on Etsy and eBay to see which marketplace leaves more net profit after transaction fees, payment processing, regulatory fees, optional Etsy Offsite Ads, eBay category fees, and VAT on eBay marketplace fees.

Last updated: 2026-03-25

Fee logic last verified: 2026-03-25

Calculator

£
£
£
£
£

Marketplace fee breakdown

See which fee layers are making the order heavier on Etsy or eBay before you treat one side as the obvious winner.

Etsy Transaction Fee—
Etsy Processing Fee—
Etsy Regulatory Fee—
Etsy Offsite Ads Fee—
Etsy Listing Fee Estimate—
Etsy Total Fees—
eBay Variable Fee—
eBay Per Order Fee—
eBay Regulatory Fee—
eBay Vat On Fees—
eBay Total Fees—
Fee Difference—

What the result means

Use the output to answer the real listing question: where does this exact order survive better after marketplace costs, and what is flipping the winner?

  • Which platform leaves more money after fees and your fulfillment costs on the same sale?
  • Is Etsy losing because its baseline stack is already heavy, or because Offsite Ads turned a close order into a weak one?
  • Is eBay losing because of category logic and VAT treatment, or because the order size itself makes the fee mix less efficient?

Where Etsy usually gets heavier

Etsy pressure usually comes from the stack rather than one single line. Transaction fee, payment processing, Regulatory Operating fee, and listing fee are always there, and Offsite Ads can turn a close comparison into a blowout when the order is attributed to Etsy advertising.

  • The baseline Etsy stack is already multi-layered before advertising is added.
  • Offsite Ads can add 12% or 15% on top of the rest, which is often the biggest reason a previously workable order turns weak.
  • That is why Etsy can look acceptable at one price point and materially worse again once ads or lower ticket pricing enter the picture.

Where eBay usually gets heavier

eBay often looks simpler at first glance, but the real drag depends on category, the order-value threshold for the per-order fee, the 0.35% regulatory operating fee, and whether you need to view marketplace fees with VAT included.

  • Category choice matters because the variable fee is not one flat eBay number.
  • Orders above £10 now trigger the 40p per-order fee, which can quietly change the result on the same basket.
  • Because eBay publishes business-seller fees exclusive of VAT, the VAT toggle is not cosmetic; it can materially change the comparison.

The biggest flip points: Offsite Ads, category, VAT, order size

Most Etsy-vs-eBay winners do not flip randomly. They flip when one of a small number of pressure points changes.

  • Turning Etsy Offsite Ads on can overwhelm a sale that looked fine under baseline Etsy fees.
  • Switching the eBay category can materially lower or raise the variable-fee side of the comparison.
  • Low-ticket orders feel fixed-fee pressure harder, while VAT on eBay fees can widen the gap again depending on how you model the business cost.

How this Etsy vs eBay comparison works

order_total = item_price + shipping_charged
etsy_total_fees = Etsy transaction fee + Etsy Payments processing fee + Etsy Regulatory Operating fee + optional Offsite Ads fee + estimated listing fee
eBay_total_fees = category-based eBay final value fee + per-order fee + eBay regulatory operating fee + optional VAT on marketplace fees
cost_total = product_cost + packaging_cost + shipping_cost
etsy_net_profit = order_total - etsy_total_fees - cost_total
ebay_net_profit = order_total - eBay_total_fees - cost_total
winner = platform with the higher net profit on the same order
  • This page keeps the order constant on both sides so the result reflects marketplace fee pressure, not a different product or shipping scenario.
  • The Etsy listing fee uses the current public UK display amount of about £0.15, but Etsy bills listings at USD 0.20 so the exact local-currency debit can move slightly.
  • The VAT toggle is only on the eBay side because eBay publishes business-seller fees exclusive of VAT, while this page models Etsy from the UK seller-facing pricing references already shown in GBP.

Example: the same UK order on Etsy and eBay

A UK seller tests the same £35 order on both marketplaces before deciding where the listing economics still feel healthy.

  • With the same item price, shipping charged, and fulfillment cost, the first comparison shows which baseline fee stack leaves more profit before advertising or special cases distort the answer.
  • Then the seller turns Etsy Offsite Ads on to see whether the Etsy result still holds up once the order is attributed to advertising.
  • That makes the page useful for a real channel decision, not just a headline fee comparison.

Before you rely on this result: key assumptions

  • This comparison models a UK Etsy seller using Etsy Payments and an eBay UK business seller only. It is not a global Etsy vs eBay calculator.
  • The Etsy side uses the published 6.5% transaction fee, the UK-facing 4% + £0.20 processing fee display, the UK Regulatory Operating fee of 0.32%, optional Offsite Ads logic, and the current public UK listing-fee display estimate.
  • Etsy states listings are billed at USD 0.20, so the exact GBP listing debit can vary slightly from the public UK display amount used here.
  • When Offsite Ads is enabled, the page applies Etsy’s published 12% or 15% rate and uses the maintained GBP estimate already stored in SellerMaths for the published USD 100 order-level cap.
  • The eBay side uses the UK business seller fee tables after the 12 February 2026 update, including the 40p per-order fee above £10 and the 0.35% regulatory operating fee.
  • The VAT toggle is a decision view, not tax advice. It helps you see the eBay fee-only versus fee-plus-VAT scenario on the same order.

Model the next step after the winner

Once you know which marketplace looks stronger on this order, move into a platform-specific calculator to test break-even price, ad pressure, or the full eBay fee view before changing where you list.

Open the Etsy break-even calculatorOpen the Etsy Offsite Ads calculatorOpen the eBay UK fee calculator

Check the trust layer behind this comparison

Use these trust routes before changing platform strategy from one side-by-side result.

How this comparison is built

See how SellerMaths holds the order constant before comparing Etsy and eBay on the same sale.

Open methodology

See source logic

Review the fee-policy, seller-facing pricing, VAT, and marketplace-update sources behind this page.

Open sources

Read why this is still an estimate

See where compare-page outputs stop and seller judgment about tax treatment, ad attribution, and exact billing still matters.

Open disclaimer

FAQ

Is Etsy or eBay better for low-ticket handmade items?

Often the answer depends on how hard the fixed and stacked fees hit the order. Etsy can feel heavier because several fee lines stack together, while eBay can still change materially by category and VAT treatment. This page shows which side survives better on your actual order instead of assuming one platform always wins.

How much can Etsy Offsite Ads change the result?

A lot. Etsy Offsite Ads can add 15% for shops under the $10,000 threshold or 12% at $10,000 and above, subject to Etsy’s published order cap. That can turn a close Etsy result into a clearly weaker one on the same sale.

Why can eBay win even when its headline category fee looks high?

Because eBay is not usually a stacked-fee system in the same way Etsy is. On some orders, especially when Offsite Ads are not involved and the category rate is reasonable, eBay can still leave more profit after the order-level math is complete.

Why does VAT change the eBay side of the comparison?

Because eBay states that its UK business-seller fees are displayed exclusive of VAT. Many sellers need to see both the fee-only and fee-plus-VAT view before deciding whether the order economics still work.

Does Etsy always cost more than eBay?

No. Etsy does not always lose, and eBay does not always win. The answer depends on price point, shipping, Etsy Offsite Ads, eBay category, and whether you need to view eBay marketplace fees with VAT included.

Is this result valid for private eBay sellers or non-UK Etsy sellers?

No. This page is intentionally narrow: UK Etsy seller logic on one side and eBay UK business-seller logic on the other. Private-seller and non-UK cases can follow different fee rules and should not be treated as interchangeable with this result.

Related next steps

Related calculators

Learn more

Compare or example

Sources

Open the Etsy break-even calculatorOpen the eBay UK fee calculatorUse the free profit margin template